Omit basic lands from salt sum

 avatar
krunschy avatarkrunschy
{"ops":[{"insert":"If you've ever wondered, why your monocolored decks have a much higher salt sum than they multicolored counterparts, you're not alone. It just so happens that basic lands have a comparatively high salt score, ranging from .28 to .76, which really adds up over 30-ish basics. It might not sound like a lot, but compare that to manafixing lands of all powerlevels and you'll average like .1 to .2. For example it's thanks to this effect that a dedicated hatebear deck (https://archidekt.com/decks/4326293?utm_source=edhrec&utm_medium=deck_summary) can be about as salty as a meme crab deck (https://archidekt.com/decks/6415503?utm_source=edhrec&utm_medium=deck_summary).\nAnd I get why this is the case. When you get these cards get suggested to rate on the salt scale, you're not rating the card, you're rating the color they represent. But this evaluation really doesn't make any sense whatsoever when it comes to calculating salt sum.\nAnd it's not as simple as temporarily removing the basics from your deck and seeing how it affects the salt sum either. The salt sum really only ever means something once compared to other decks, but every decks sum is just as skewed.\nThat's why I'm suggesting to just not count basics for the salt score at all. I'm aware this swings the pendulum in the opposite direction a bit, meaning multicolored decks will have a tad more salt for their manafixing lands, but as stated previously those count for way less, so it's way less of an inaccuracy. There surely is an even smarter way to solve this issue, but it's also likely more complicated too. Simply omitting basics however appears easy enough to implement, while greatly mitigating the issue.\n"}]}
1
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"We've heard this suggestion before, but we've decided that we won't be updating how the salt sums are calculated. \n\nAs you alluded to, reweighting by removing or limitting basics disproportionaltly effects multi-colored decks. It's a robing Peter to pay Paul sort of situation. And since all of these numbers are crowed sourced anyway, we don't feel it's our place to fiddle with where the data leads. \n\nWe are aware that the fact that some basics being a higher salt score than others is mostly a meme, but it's a meme the community has continued to perpetuate for the past 3 (however many EDHREC has been putting out that salt voting survey) years, and we don't think it's our place to fiddle with those numbers. \n\nEspecially when taking into consideration the fact that the intent of a salt sum on the site was always meant as more of a gag stat anyway. \n"}]}
0
 avatar
krunschy avatarkrunschy
{"ops":[{"insert":"I see that it's kinda meant to be a gag stat, given that a deck is of course a lot more than the sum of its parts in many regards, yet I do consider the metric to be a solid starting point regardless.\nAlso afaik the EDHREC salt score wasn't intended for this purpose in the first place. To my knowledge salt sum is a pure Archidekt thing, which is why I personally wouldn't consider this fiddling with their numbers at all.\nBut even with all that being said, I see your point nonetheless. Maybe things change sometime to warrant this change...\n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads