Tags for Purchase Status or Progress Status

 avatar
Octathorp avatarOctathorp
{"ops":[{"insert":"I recognize that tags are meant to be searchable for others to find desks they are interested in. But I would REALLY love to be able to utilize them to sort and organize my own decks. Things like color typing are there and that's great. But the thing I'd really like is to be able to note the purchased status or deck building, things like \"To Buy\" , \"Owned\" , or even \"Completed\" or \"In Progress\". Right now I use folders for that, but it gets kinda messy that way. It would be great if I could use the tags in that way to help out.\n"}]}
1
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hmm, as you allude to, we definitely don't want to conflate the purpose of deck tags. I'm not actually sure they'd help in this instance anyway since you'd need to perform deck searches (probably from \"My Decks\"), filtering by tag. Those searches are going to be a fair bit slower than navigating through your folder, so I think the experience would be pretty subpar. \n\nCould you explain in what ways using folders to organize by these characteristics gets messy? I'd be more interested in improving on that system to fix the problem than offloading it to a different, ostensibly unrelated feature. \n"}]}
0
 avatar
Octathorp avatarOctathorp
{"ops":[{"insert":"Sure, happy to explain. My goal is to go from seeing all of my decks, to seeing the particular subgroups of decks fairly quickly. When using folders there isn't an easy way to make that transition. You are either looking at the un-categorized version in the card style layout in \"My Decks\", which I overall enjoy. Ideally, I could filter through these different elements right there. But since the folder system is in place, things can't be categorized by multiple facets, and it uses a file system instead of a search/filter system. So in order to look around at different decks I want to try to tweak, I'm clicking through a different style of list interface, and going through multiple folders (I currently have it set up as \"Need A lot of Work\", \"Still Tweaking\", , \"Complete\" and \"Owned\") trying to find the right deck to edit. \n\nJust in general, a filter / search / tag system for organization would allow you to have the benefit of folders (sub-segmenting your overall deck pool) but allow you to do it in multiple ways simultaneously. So then I could have something tagged ex. Rakdos, In-Progress, Modern, Owned, Sacrifice, Tokens, Budget. And if I had a need to filter through any of those options, I'd be able to do so (say a new cool \"Rakdos\" card comes out so I want to see which deck it could go in, or I just want to sit down and finish some decks so I look at \"In-Progress\", maybe a Modern night is coming up so I want to look through my modern builds). A lot of these are about the value of organizing and understanding my own collection without having to get a bunch of deckboxes out in-person. So my ability to sort is very important, and the folder system just doesn't allow for that style of flexibility. I have to choose one binning strategy and go with it, and then instead of changing elements being as easy as adjusting a couple of tag titles, I have to fiddle with touchy click-and-drag features trying to pull a deck out of a sub-folder and back into the main pool to then drag back into another sub-folder. \n\nI hope that properly illustrates my point of view. I don't really agree with your initial statement overall. The My Decks page looks more appealing (less dead space, more card art, visually indicates the weight of the color for each deck, not just what colors are there. has the ability to show the tags of the deck right by the name to basically give a summary of the deck), it has more direct access to my decks (there aren't in sub-folders and there are bigger touch targets to select the deck you want), and so then the last step is just to be able to access the specific ones I need (through the addition of a filter for instance, right now I use the advanced card filter option), that would be much easier than clicking through sub-folders in a file system. Even now when I'm looking for a deck, my go to flow is to go to \"My Decks\" , open the 'Advancesd' search settings, and enter in the name of the main cards in the deck I'm trying to find into the \"Card\" filter option. I find this much easier and faster than navigating through folders and visually scanning through a list of deck names to pinpoint the one I'm looking for (which hopefully I remember exactly what I titled it). So when I see the \"No Deck Tags\" space, in My Decks I just think about how useful it would be for me to be able to use that for my own organization.\n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads