Feature Request: Commander Codex

 avatar
babymando avatarbabymando
{"ops":[{"insert":"Just found out about Commander Codex, and I love playing it daily! I don't often get to play mtg these days but it is a favored past time of mine.\n\nI started playing back in 2018, so I am still somewhat new to the game. I find it difficult to narrow down my options once I have correctly guessed aspects of the daily commander (i.e., I have figured out the commander is 4 CMC and power + toughness = 8, or is possibly a shaman, druid, or treefolk creature type). I do not have the time nor patience to scroll through the top 500 card list that is available for the puzzle, so I eventually end up guessing random commanders that I know are incorrect just so that I can figure out who the commander is. \n\nThe feature I am requesting is a filtering mechanism within the \"View Cards\" section of the game. It would function similarly to MTG Companions advanced search tools, but would not need to be as verbose but could still be rather barebones. A field with a list of creature types, CMCs, power + toughness values, color combinations, etc. This would allow me to take it from 500 potential commanders to 100 to 50 as I continue to play the game, and would increase my engagement. I also imagine I wouldn't throw in the towel so quickly as I only have a small amount of the MTG library catalogued and indexed in my brain.\n\nI think this feature would help the majority of the people playing this game, not just me. Even if all of the fields weren't filterable and only some (CMC, color identity, power+toughness only), it would greatly increase the playability for folks like me who enjoy the game but have not thoroughly studied/mapped the majority of popular cards, or even are aware of many cards that preceded when they started playing (I am most familiar with cards 2018 and on).\n\nI really enjoy this game, and want to keep playing, I just also want to enjoy trying until the end without the thought of getting to round 5 with a few of the categories nailed down but knowing I would have to parse through all 500 looking at each card's attributes before making a guess. \n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"First of all, I'm so glad you're enjoying Commander Codex! It's a relatively small side project, but one we feel pretty proud of. It's always awesome to hear of someone playing it regularly.\n\nAs for your request, this is definitely something we considered early on, but ultimately decided against implementing. The fact of the matter is, as soon as you can perform a search with each piece of information you've gathered plugged in, solving the game can become quite trivial. I totally understand getting to a point where you know exactly what you're looking for, you just don't know the card, and a search would let you actually finish the game. I've gotten to that point too and have absolutely used a search to finish it. We're just hesitant to put that search right in front of people because it may be too tempting to just do that for every guess, removing any sort of challenge to the game. The grid of the top 500 commanders was a compromise between doing the search and doing nothing. \n\nMy suggestion would be to pull up a search on Archidekt or "},{"attributes":{"link":"https://scryfall.com/"},"insert":"Scryfall"},{"insert":" if you find yourself wanting one. I understand that just feels like we're adding an unnecessary hurdle for you and I apologize for that, but we feel it's best for the longevity of the game to have them separate. \n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads