Some suggested tags going through decks

 avatar
Swizard avatarSwizard
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hello everyone,\nI'd like to contribute to the discussion about tags by sharing my decklists and suggesting a few additional tags:\n\nMulticolor (e.g. Rhamos - cards that synergize with multiple colors; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53218/dragon_edh"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53218/dragon_edh"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Self-destruct (perhaps called burn?; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2987912/creature_go_boommm_edh"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2987912/creature_go_boommm_edh"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Creature cheat (not exactly sneak attack, more like Elvish Piper; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53216/mayael_the_timmy_captain_edh"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53216/mayael_the_timmy_captain_edh"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Life loss/life as a resource (popularized by commander K'rrik; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/190001/krrik_nasty_b_edh_deck"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/190001/krrik_nasty_b_edh_deck"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Free casts (e.g. Jhoira with cost reduction and card draw; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/177707/jhoira_cherios_edh"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/177707/jhoira_cherios_edh"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"ETB / Enter the Battlefield (more about Panharmonicon/Yarok than bounce; see "},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/153091/yarok_the_panharmonicon_landfall_deck"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/153091/yarok_the_panharmonicon_landfall_deck"},{"insert":")"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"(Note: \"Aura\" and \"Auras\" appear as two separate tags; should they be combined?)"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\nAdditionally, would it be possible to include brief descriptions for each tag in the search bar? This would help users unfamiliar with specific terminology better engage with the tags.\n\n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hi there! I think there are some good suggestions here. I'll respond to each.\n\nI definitely want a tag for this, I just haven't come up with a satisfactory name. I don't think just \"Multicolor\" works, because folks make just end up using it to tag any multicolor deck, rendering it useless as a search term. \"Multicolor Matters\" is probably correct, I've just never liked the sound of it so I've procrastinated adding it, hoping I'd come up with something better. I think it's the best option though, so that's what I've added."},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\"Self-Destruct\" is reasonably succinct, added. "},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"I actually sorta wish we hadn't used \"Sneak Attack\" at all and went with a more general term like \"Creature Cheat\". All Sneak Attack decks are probably Creature Cheat decks but not the other way around. I'm not a huge fan of making a tag that entirely encompasses one we already have, but I'll give it some thought."},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"This is a good one, but I've gone with \"Life Paying\" to keep it succinct. I think that's sufficiently descriptive. "},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\"Free Casts\" sounds too nebulous to me. Can we workshop this one?"},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\"ETB Effects\" should definitely be one, yeah. Added."},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Yeah, the Aura/Auras and Constructs/Contructs tags need to be combined but not deleted so no one loses preexisting tags. It's just going to be a little annoying so we're finishing some other projects we're working on first. "},{"attributes":{"list":"ordered"},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\nAs for tag descriptions, we had decided early on that we didn't want to do them for a couple of reasons. First, we didn't really want to engage in debates over what exactly qualifies as \"Tempo\" or \"Aggro\" (for instance). We also didn't want to it too feel to users as if there's a right or wrong answer to whether their decks should be tagged a certain way. If we include a description for a tag that looks like it fits your deck even though it's not something you personally would have called it, we don't want you to feel obligated to use it. Nor do we want to resulting experience of thinking \"Oh damn, if I didn't think of that one, what else did I miss?\", followed by scrolling through nearly 300 tags. That might sound fun to some users, but others may find it overwhelming and lead them to not interact with tags at all for fear of getting something \"wrong\". It's possible our stance on this will change eventually (especially if we have a ton of users requesting it), but that's where our heads are at right now.\n\nRegardless, thank you for the detailed suggestions! There were some great ideas in there and I appreciate the help in improving our tagging system. \n"}]}
1
 avatar
Swizard avatarSwizard
{"ops":[{"insert":"Regarding the first suggestion, perhaps either \"Multicolor Synergy,\" the original \"Multicolor Matters,\" or \"Multicolor Focus\" as potential tags.\n\nFor the fifth suggestion, consider the following: \"No-Cost Casts,\" \"Zero-Cost Casting,\" \"Discounted Casting,\" \"Mana Reduction Spells,\" or \"Cost-Efficient Magic.\"\n\nAdditionally, a new tag suggestion would be related to the \"your death matters\" theme popularised by Teysa Karlov. Could be \"Death Triggers\" or \"Death Benefits,\" ("},{"attributes":{"color":"var(--tw-prose-links)","link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/220061/teysa_your_death_matters"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/220061/teysa_your_death_matters"},{"insert":").\n\nFor the last suggestion, I'm not sure how much you want to go into sub-themes. For example, Jeleva's deck strategy can be more about \"casting your stuff\" than just \"theft.\" This unique theme not only creates different gameplay experiences but also gets a lot of support. To better represent this strategy, you might consider a more specific tag like \"Spell Hijacking\", \"Casting Appropriation\", \"Opponent's Arsenal\", \"Spell Borrowing\" or \"Yoinked Magic\". (Example of what I mean: "},{"attributes":{"link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53209/jeleva_stealing_stuff"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/53209/jeleva_stealing_stuff"},{"insert":"). These suggested tags highlight the deck's focus on using opponents' cards and strategies, giving a more accurate idea of the theme.\n\nAs a middle ground solution, it could to create a dedicated 'help' page that explains each tag's purpose. This page could be accessed through a help button, offering people a better understanding of the available tags and their meanings.\n"}]}
Edited 4/27/2023, 11:21:29 AM
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads