Owned cards when comparing community decks to collection

 avatar
Alderan avatarAlderan
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hello,\n\nwhen comparing Community decks to my MTG Arena collection I notice that the cards are tagged as \"Owned\" even I don't own all the cards needed to complete the selected deck. I presume the the tag \"Owned\" is shown when you have in collection at least 1 copy of the card, not considering if you have all of them to complete the deck.\n\nFor example in the Explorer deck \"UW Control\" (Last Edited: Tue Nov 01 2022) the 4 copies of the "},{"attributes":{"bold":true,"link":"https://mtgarena.pro/cards/#expansion-13"},"insert":"Ravnica Allegiance"},{"attributes":{"bold":true},"insert":" "},{"insert":"card \"Absorb\" are tagged \"Owned\" even if I have in collection only 1 copy of this card.\n\nI think that after the number of cards needed to complete the deck there should be a number, maybe between round brackets, indicating the number of cards actually owned in collection. \n\nFor the above example   4 (1)    and so on\n\nI don't know if this implicate a lot of work to reorganize the Community decks but I hope you will consider this feature request as, at the moment, comparing these decks to the collection is absolutely useless.\n\nBest regards\n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"You are correct in your assessment: a green stripe means that you own at least one copy of that exact card in your collection, while a blue stripe indicates that you only own a different version of that card. There is currently no indication of whether you own enough copies of the card in question to meet the quantity in the deck.\n\nThe reason we haven't expanded on this system (yet) is because we haven't come up with an elegant way to do it with the stripes. For instance, it might be easy enough to add a yellow strip to indicate that you have some but not enough copies of the card, but is that enough? Should there be a different color for indicating that you need one, two or three+ more copies? How do we reconcile that with different card versions? If you own one copy of an exact match of a card and one copy of a different version, what does that look like if there are two in the deck? In short, it's definitely possible for us to do, but it needs to be simple enough for new users to understand while simultaneously satisfying more entrenched users looking for a robust system. It's tricky.\n\nThat said, we do have a thread up for this in our Feature Voting subforum. Many other users have indicated interest in some sort of expansion on this feature over there, so I'd suggest adding your voice to theirs with a comment and/or upvote. Features that generate more interest from the community are more likely to receive priority from us in development.\n\n"},{"attributes":{"link":"https://archidekt.com/forum/thread/2349823/1"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/forum/thread/2349823/1"},{"insert":"\n\nI apologize for not having a more immediate solution for you, but hope the reasoning for why we haven't put something together yet makes sense. Regardless, thank you for reaching out with the suggestion!\n"}]}
0
 avatar
Alderan avatarAlderan
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hello Jeremy,\n\nno need to apologize and thank you for the fast reply to my post. I understand your point of view and I acknowledge that Arckidekt is more oriented towards MTG collectors and decks' brewers than towards casual players like me but are colored stripes really necessary when comparing Community decks to collection ? If the colored stripes doesn't completely reflect the real condition of the collection what's the point to have them in Community decks' section ? \nMy personal opinion is that numbers are more appropriate for this purpose, as I suggested in my previous post; for completing the deck the card's printing doesn't matter if the card is legal for a specific format.\nAt the moment I have to check every card, at least rares or mythic rares, tagged as \"Owned\" to see if I have all the needed copies in collection or not to complete the deck. This is, frankly, a waste of time and I could to do this even without the colored stripes, of course.\nAnyway thank you for your work to maintain Archidekt website, maybe I'l post a suggestion to Feature Voting subforum and I hope that something will change regarding this issue.\n\nBest regards\n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads