{"ops":[{"insert":"The new card details screen is a little awkward. It's split into two parts, with important info requiring an extra click to access. The buttons on the first screen also look odd because they're literally twice as wide as they need to be. I made a quick and dirty sketch of the two screens merged into one. What do you think?\n\n\n"},{"insert":{"image":"https://i.imgur.com/H1nbNAq.png"}},{"insert":"\n"}]}
0
{"ops":[{"insert":"The design of the card form/details page is something we spent a "},{"attributes":{"italic":true},"insert":"long"},{"insert":" time tweaking for this past update, but that doesn't mean we got everything right on the first pass! Let me address why we didn't do things as you have pictured above and see where that leaves us:\n\nFirst off, the buttons under \"Card options\", \"Categories\", and \"Other options\" (to a lesser extent), are generally used with far more frequency than anything under the \"Card Details\" portion of the menu. For this reason, they had to be shown first. So if we were to go with everything on a single screen, that would definitely need to go on top. Their size is an aesthetic choice, primarily predicated on the fact that we don't want too many buttons in one horizontal line. We could have them smaller with more empty space, but that simply looked worse than allowing them to take up the space available to them. \n\nThat said, we made the conscious decision "},{"attributes":{"italic":true},"insert":"not"},{"insert":" to include everything on a single screen because it's just too much visual clutter. While there's certainly something to be said for seeing all of this information in one place without need for an extra click, if the information is less comprehensible because of its volume, it's not worth it. \n\nIn general, we're not expecting users to need the information under the \"Card Details\" portion of the menu as frequently-- this includes the card's oracle text, salt score, and format legalities. In fact, pre update, this data used to be on an entirely different page. So the improvement that we were going for is that on the occasions you are looking for any of that information, you at least don't have to leave the context of the deck page or Search menu in order to do it. \n\nSo I guess my question to you is whether you're finding yourself navigating the the \"Card Details\" portion of that menu frequently? It's certainly possible we need to recalibrate our expectations for what functions users want prioritized, but that doesn't seem to be the case based on the data available to us.\n\nRegardless, I appreciate you reaching and and the effort to make the mock-up! \n"}]}
0
{"ops":[{"insert":"I had forgotten about this post...\n\nI'm sure you're right about the buttons being used more. I only need the card text if the picture is non-English, like for some leaked pre-release cards. Honestly, what bothers me about having two different sections in dialog is:\n\nA. Clicking 'Show Card Details' has an unnecessarily slow animation (it should be 2-4x speed)\nB. It and the 'Show Card Form' button are in different places, which I find unintuitive\n\nAlso it's not clear where the edges of the dialog are if I want to click outside to close it. IIRC this wasn't an issue before the update. Adding a border would be an easy solution.\n"}]}
0