{"ops":[{"insert":"I find it very frustrating when playing Commander Codex when I guess a card and get a yellow result (partial match) on Color identity...\nDo I guess mono-colored cards that can't possibly be the right answer to get a handle on the correct color identity or do I guess cards that could be possible knowing that I will likely get zero info on color?\n\nCurrently the reply for color identity is:\nBlack - Nothing matches\nYellow - at least one thing matches, but it isn't an exact match\nGreen - Exact match\n\nI think the game would be more enjoyable if slightly more information was given for color ID replies...\nBlack - Nothing Matches (same as before)\nYellow - Mixed results, something matches but something doesn't match\nBlue - Everything in your guess matches, but it isn't an exact match\nGreen - Exact Match (same as before)\n\nThis means that if the answer is Osgir, the Reconstructor and my first guess is Akroma, Angel of Fury I will get a BLUE reply on color identity (instead of the yellow I would get today). Functionally my knowledge is the same as it is today, I know that the color identity includes two or more colors and that one of those colors is red. Let's say my second guess is Brudiclad, Telchor Engineer, I would now get a yellow result on color identity (same as currently) but my actual knowledge is now greater... I know that the correct answer is more than one color, one of those colors is Red, and Blue is NOT in the color identity.\n\nThis does two things, one it encourages guesses that could be correct over guesses that could not be correct but provide more information (like guessing a mono-blue commander as the second guess above to get the same information without it being possible to get the right answer on two), secondly it encourages players to guess two (or more) colored commanders in their opening guess as more information is provided for those guesses (currently (and likely even after this change) there is a very strong incentive to guess a mono colored card for guess one as it narrows the field the most.\n\nA second possible change I would like to suggest would be permitting the guessing of ANY possible commander, not just the top 500, with correct answers still only coming from the top 500... Sometimes the perfect guess exists but not in the top 500 and it makes me sad...\n"}]}
0
{"ops":[{"insert":"I forgot to mention that if you were guessing something not in the top 500 the guess confirmation screen should state that (NOTE: this guess is not in the top 500)\n"}]}
0