Why are we using Pie Charts?

 avatar
leetortilla avatarleetortilla
{"ops":[{"insert":"I'm no pro at data analysis but if we use a pie chart for data with mixed categories or types doesn't this lead to misconceptions? The total percentage will not equate to 100 and this is very apparent in the mana source vs production chart especially when you choose to show colorless.\nCan we do percentages instead? Moxfield has a great design for this. Can archidekt copy their stat displays?\n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"An argument can definitely be made for using something other than a pie chart for card types. The relationship between the pie slices doesn't mean a ton and that information could be more logically conveyed another. \n\nMana costs vs. production, however, I actually feel the pie chart is excellent for. I think what you're missing there is that we count number of mana symbols rather than cards specifically for the relationship it indicates between cost and production. For instance, "},{"insert":{"card-link":"Avacyn, Angel of Hope"}},{"insert":" contributes 3 white to the mana cost portion of a deck's pie chart. This means she'll make the white portion of the cost pie appear larger than a card like "},{"insert":{"card-link":"Mentor of the Meek"}},{"insert":". In order to make your production pie match up closer with your cost pie, you'd need more white sources to account for Avacyn than Mentor. It's all about this visual this creates (which will adjust in real time as you add or remove cards) which I feel is more comprehensible than throwing percentages at users that require a bunch of caveats. Moxfield's implementation is definitely thorough, but I feel it doesn't adequately convey the relationship between costs and production. \n\nOf course, this is all super subjective and nobody would be wrong for preferring a different view. There are certainly improvements that should be made to our stats tab, but I think that will be mostly in the form of additions rather than replacements. \n"}]}
0
 avatar
leetortilla avatarleetortilla
{"ops":[{"insert":"Okay so here's an example: "},{"attributes":{"link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2394573#Pie_Charts"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2394573#Pie_Charts"},{"insert":"\nWhen I first saw the pie charts my intuition led to think that I would actually want to match up the colors for the inner pie and the outer pie. Which makes sense. You want to match your production with the cost demands. So okay. We want to find a visual that relates the symbol cost to symbol production.\nYour point on mana symbols vs color production does help me understand where you coming from, more symbols would mean more weight for the production demand. So sure the outer ring can be the pie of all color symbols. But I add in a card like unmake. It's total symbol count is 6. It overpowers the rest of the symbols when the 'weight' of that card's demand is only 3 symbols. If I use a card like that the stats get slightly innacurate because the demand is not properly represented anymore.\nAlso, in the example above 100% of the lands produce all colors of mana. AND YET in a pie chart in that example what you'll see is that your production implies you make 20% of each. I can for sure cast unmake but the pie charts don't match up.\nTo show my point further here is another example that has the exact same pie chart as the first one BUT can't actually cast unmake.\n"},{"attributes":{"link":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2394783#Pie_Charts_2"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/2394783#Pie_Charts_2"},{"insert":"\nIf you use pie charts a full set of 5 color producing lands looks exactly the same as equal numbers of all basics. There is something wrong with that in terms of matching production and demand.\n\nFor rough deck building I say these piecharts are fine but for fine tuning I feel like they do more harm than good.\nIf the point of the graphs is to show that your symbol production can match up with your symbol demand then I feel we should not mix the colors in one pie chart since they kind mess with each other's weights because of the mixed colors.\n\n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads