Why does the Jolly balloon man and village bell ringer cause an infinity combo? Est Commander Bracket: Optimized (4)?

 avatar
{"ops":[{"attributes":{"color":"#222222"},"insert":"Why does the Jolly balloon man and village bell ringer cause an infinity combo? Wouldn't it require a tap-able mana dork?"},{"insert":"\n\n"},{"attributes":{"color":"#222222"},"insert":"Why are these two cards enough for Est Commander Bracket: Optimized (4)?"},{"insert":"\n\n"},{"attributes":{"color":"#222222"},"insert":"I feel like that should stay in Bracket 2?"},{"insert":"\n\n"},{"attributes":{"color":"#222222"},"insert":"https://archidekt.com/decks/19868325/jolly_test"},{"insert":"\n\n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"All 2 card combos on the site that we take into account for brackets were decided by a vote held by edhrec to determin whether or not the community considered it relevant for brackets. So long as a combo is listed on commander spellbook as only requiring 2 cards it was considered, from there the community voted on whether or not the prerequisites of the combo made the combo feel like it was in the spirit of what the bracket system was going for. \n\nHere's the thing. Nearly every two cars combo in the game requires some kind of other thing to either start the loop, or something along those lines. The quintessential 2 card combo of "},{"insert":{"card-link":"Exquisite Blood"}},{"insert":" and "},{"insert":{"card-link":"Sanguine Bond"}},{"insert":" require something to happen (aka a third card) to start the loop. And very few would argue that is not a two card combo. \n\nThat reasoning is why the vote was held by edhrec at all was to figure out whether or not the \"thing\" that starts the loop was trivial enough to still consider the combo as something the bracket system was talking about. People said that having a dork around was trivial enough to \"oops\" into, that the combo should be considered. \n\nNow, our estimator is built to help you better understand your deck, and help facilitate conversations about it. If you disagree with the estimator, that's totally fine, and you can set the bracket of your deck manually vis the deck's settings. We also don't pay attention to more nuianced parts to your deck (like whether or not the deck has a mana dork in it). So feel free to set your deck to whatever you link. The estimator is there to help you, not tell you what the power level of your deck is. \n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"But if it needs a mana dork doesn't it make it a 3 card combo, and not a 2 card combo? Shouldn't that stay in "},{"attributes":{"color":"#222222"},"insert":"Bracket"},{"insert":" 2 then?\n"}]}
0
Support us on Patreon to remove ads