Remove Category (From Cards or From Deck)

 avatar
itsjustpyro avataritsjustpyro
{"ops":[{"insert":"When playing around with deck structures, I don't like the default categories, or I end up in a spot where cards end up with categories they shouldn't have anymore. Sometimes they hold onto the default card type categories, and some hold onto the sideboard or maybeboard categories.\n\nI'd like to be able to select a category, and remove all cards from said category. \nAlternatively it'd be useful to select one or more cards and then remove categories from them if they exist. \nAlso alternatively it'd be nice to have cards come in without any categories.\n\nI find the default community tags not always helpful for how I plan decks. And I find the card-type categories redundant and annoying when attempting to structure a deck. \n\n"}]}
0
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"Edit: Sorry, I'm realizing I'm testing comment stuff on a real thread lol. Please disregard 😂\n"}]}
1
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"I find the default community tags not always helpful for how I plan decks"},{"attributes":{"blockquote":true},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\nLet's start with this one. In case you didn't know, community categories can be disabled via your account settings. (Though I can't tell if you want them on but just sometimes don't like them, either way I figured I'd mention it just in case).\n\nI'd like to be able to select a category, and remove all cards from said category. Alternatively it'd be useful to select one or more cards and then remove categories from them if they exist. "},{"attributes":{"blockquote":true},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\nYou should be able to do this by selecting all the cards in a category (via the three dot menu next to the category header). From there you can move those cards where you might want them to go via the multi edit controls. \n\nUnless you're specifically talking about removing categories ONLY. In which case, we don't allow that since doing so will end up moving cards all over the place without much awareness on the user's end as to what the heck just happened. Doing so would basically be akin to move all of the selected cards to their auto cateogries (which you can do if this is what you want). We've had this option before, and users have found it unintuitive enough that we just removed it. This might work if cards were allowed to not have any categories, but there are reasons why we don't allow that either. Which is a good lead in to:\n\nAlso alternatively it'd be nice to have cards come in without any categories."},{"attributes":{"blockquote":true},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"\nWe don't allow for this because categories are what determins a card's position within the deck (eg: Included in the deck (non maybeboard), commander, etc). Removing all categories breaks that relationship, and goes against how Archidekt's underlying datastructures are built. Removing that requirement at this point would be extremely difficult (if not impossible). Even if we could spend a lot of time removing that requirement, I'm not sure I'd want to, since the current implementation (deck position being determined by categories) has a lot of benefits for deck organization that would be a bit cumbersom if deck position weren't bound to categories. \n\nIf you want to ignore categories nearly completely, a decent workflow may be to set your group by option to Type. Doing so hides most of the cateogry information, and present the deck more akin to a less personalized and more objective decklist.\n"}]}
1
 avatar
itsjustpyro avataritsjustpyro
{"ops":[{"insert":"I've got the default tags off, but that means each card gets tagged with just it's card type. Appreciate the tip and see how I was unclear there. \n\nWe've had this option before, and users have found it unintuitive enough that we just removed it. "},{"attributes":{"blockquote":true},"insert":"\n"},{"insert":"Makes sense. That is the option I would want, but between this and your next paragraph I see why you don't have it as a feature (anymore). Or why the data-structure is setup for a card to not have any categories. \n\nGood news is that I had somewhat misunderstood how autocategories work. If adding a custom category to a card, they'll get sorted back to that if you use autocategories. I had misunderstood since if a card only has a category Sideboard, and gets auto-categoried. It'll get the default automatic category, which has just tripped me up. \n"}]}
1
Support us on Patreon to remove ads