Land color production for Eventide filter lands

 avatar
joelvdc avatarjoelvdc
{"ops":[{"insert":"Hey!\n\nI noticed that when adding the Eventide filter lands ("},{"insert":{"card-link":"Fetid Heath"}},{"insert":", "},{"insert":{"card-link":"Twilight Mire"}},{"insert":" , etc.), they count for 3 pips of each color instead of just 1 pip like the other duals. I guess this is because these lands have 3 of each mana symbol in their activated ability?\n\nI think that counting for 3 pips is too much and deceiving when checking your color production in your deck. I think that having these lands count for only 1 pip of each color would be more correct. Maybe one could argue for 2 color pips, but their ability also demands a colored pip to activate, so I think 1 color pip would be better.\n"}]}
1
 avatar
{"ops":[{"insert":"Unfortunately there won't be much we can do about that. There's too many cards that do this to try to correct for this, and that's how scryfall provides mana production data.\n\nI'm not opposed to ideas if you've got any, but I can't think of a way to cover this for every card without needing to maintain an arbitrary list of cards (which is too much manual work).\n"}]}
0
 avatar
joelvdc avatarjoelvdc
{"ops":[{"insert":"After going back and forth between Archidekt and Moxfield, I noticed that they count the mana produced by lands a bit differently and I would like to leave a note here about it. \n\nInstead of counting the number of pips, they're checking if a land can produce a certain color and add that land to the total number of lands producing that color. The result is shown as \"xx out of yy lands can produce white\". IMO, that is the correct thing to do when building a mana base, but it might be too much nitpicking from my side when looking at the overall picture. Not sure if that data can be directly pulled from scryfall or if it would require some time consuming magic behind the scenes. I absolutely adore your website tho, keep up the good work!\n"}]}
1
Support us on Patreon to remove ads