MadHatter {"ops":[{"insert":"This might be a little bit of a niche suggestion, but illegal cards for the deck/format aren't represented in the maybeboard by the red outline. I use a template to brew decks which has been very useful to quickly mock up builds. Sometimes forget to cut cards that aren't in my color identity from there then I get mixed up when the deck says I have cards outside of it. (referring to the color breakdown on the \"My Deck\" homepage). It would just be a nice QoL thing but overall isn't a huge deal.\n"}]}
0
{"ops":[{"insert":"So the Maybeboard not being subject to legality checks is very intentional. I definitely can see how having red borders around cards outside of your Commander's color ID would be useful in your case, but we view \"out of deck\" categories as a place users can toss ideas without any rules imposition. I don't believe we'll be changing that.\n\nThat being said, the behavior that you're describing on your \"My Decks\" page is concerning. If, for instance, you have a mono red EDH deck with a blue card in it's Maybeboard, you're saying you'd see a blue sliver on it's color breakdown? We definitely "},{"attributes":{"italic":true},"insert":"should"},{"insert":" be ignoring out of deck categories for that color bar, so that could be a bug. \n"}]}
0
{"ops":[{"insert":"Fair enough, I figured it was a pretty niche ask. Just would be nice QoL in my case, but thanks for letting me know!\n\nAs far as the \"My Decks\" UI goes, it doesn't happen much but it has happened a few times. I'm not sure how to recreate the bug, but sometimes the color breakdown doesn't match the list. I have two decks currently that have bugged color breakdowns. Maybe I've just completely missed what cards are causing them, but I don't see any outside of the decks intended color identity. \n\nWell as I was writing this I happened to fix both examples of bugged UI I had lol. I'll post them anyway incase the team is able to look at its history or something for bugs and explain what was going on. I hope it helps lol, of course it fixes itself as I'm talking about it.\n\nhttps://archidekt.com/decks/931313#Talk_to_the_Wall\nUsed to show a sliver of red in my white, blue, green Arcades deck. This has been persistent for years (I think its been that long?) or at least way before the site's UI revamp awhile back. In writing this reply I was going through the list again, noticed I had an extra shadowspear in the maybeboard, removed it, saved, and then the red sliver was gone lol. I've updated this deck several times since coming to the site and the red sliver was always there since I first made the deck, not sure what fixed it now but it is gone.\n\nhttps://archidekt.com/decks/2873837#Faldorn_testing\nThis was a deck I made from my old template deck. It used to show slivers of black, white, and blue when it is only red and green. I don't recall if I made it before or after the site's UI changes, but it was pretty recent. I just changed its name and had no change in the color identity UI, but after seeing Arcades get fixed I removed a maybeboard card and it fixed this one too (wasn't a duplicate this time). \n\nI've had a few other decks have this color identity issue and normally they worked themselves out. Maybe through either user error on my part or forcing a refresh somehow like I'm assuming I did with my other two examples. These two were the persistent ones I couldn't (until literally right now lol) get to fix. If it comes up again I could shoot a bug report in.\n"}]}
0