hanleybrand 4 years{"ops":[{"insert":"First, off I'm a new user so it's totally possible I missed something. I've been entering my collection in, and I started with the precon decks I bought. All of them worked from published decklists (I mostly used the textports from the official MTG site), except for one, a precon brawl deck from the Eldraine set, Knights Charge. \n\nHere's my copy - https://www.archidekt.com/decks/1268920#Knights_Charge_-_precon_(Eldraine_Brawl)\n\nI have it set to Brawl, and I set the commander and everything but it's giving me legality errors for a good number of the cards, some are from War of the Spark or other sets older than Elraine.\n\nI guess technically brawl decks have to be \"standard\" cards, but what do you do with older decks? Is there a versioned list of standards? Like, I'm guessing the Eldraine brawl decks were Standard 2020 (according to"},{"attributes":{"link":"https://mtgazone.com/mtg-standard-rotation-guide/"},"insert":" this article"},{"insert":", the deck would have been standard in the last standard)\n\nOr could there maybe be a \"Casual Brawl\" format added that didn't do the standard list legality check?\n"}]}
Edited 3/31/2021, 5:41:38 PM
1
Jeremy(Archidekt Moderator)
4 years{"ops":[{"insert":"Yeah, you correctly identified the issue: Since Brawl is a rotating format, those old precons technically aren't legal anymore, much like a precon deck bought from War of the Spark wouldn't be legal in Standard anymore either.\n\nAdding a \"Casual Brawl\" might be something we'd consider if there was a demand for it, but in the interim, changing your format to \"Custom\" should get you around the legality issues you're running into. \n"}]}
1
Pawper 4 years{"ops":[{"insert":"Here to throw my support behind adding a more permissive brawl format. Just came across this issue myself last week.\n"}]}
0